Different Ways to Crochet in the Round

By Claire Ortega-Reyes – 41 Comments

When crocheting in the round, there are two different ways to progress through rows. At the end of each row, we can join the last stitch to the first by making a slip stitch at the top of the first stitch (the “traditional” way); or we can continue working on to the next round by making the first stitch for the next round on top of the first stitch of the row below (working in a spiral).

Let’s compare the two methods. I made a circle all in half double crochet, following the same pattern for both swatches, but joined differently at the end of the rows:

Joined at Row Ends

Worked in Spiral

“Traditional” Way Working in Spiral
  • There’s a slightly visible line in the work, where the ladder stitches are (in this case, the ch 2 that substitutes for one hdc stitch).
  • There are no visible lines in the work, since no ladder stitches have to be made. This also makes for a more solid construction.
  • Shape is more uniform. If you’re crocheting a circle or a square, it looks like a circle or square at the end of each round.
  • After the end of each round, the last stitch sticks out from the rest–you’d have to join it to the first stich(es) of the previous round to make it uniformly-shaped.
  • Stitches are easy to count and check for each round.
  • Beginners have to use stitch markers (see below) to keep track of the work.
  • If the pattern calls for stitches in varying heights, it would still come out uniformly-shaped.
  • When using a pattern with stitches of varying heights, the work may come out warped.

What Are Stitch Markers?

Stich markers are used to keep track of stitch counts, or your progress in a pattern. It can also be used to secure the hanging loop in your crochet work when you set it aside to do something else, to prevent the work from unraveling. Craft stores sell a lot of various kinds of stitch markers–everything from your basic plastic ones to fancy gem-laden ones.

When working in spiral, it’s going to be a little difficult to keep track of where you are in the work (unless of course you have an outstanding memory!). So we put stitch markers either at the end of each round, or in the first stitch of each round, so we know where we are. This way, we can check the number of stitches for each round.

I’ll tell you a little secret: you don’t have to spend anything at all to be able to mark your work! I actually don’t own a single one they sell at craft stores. I use everyday stuff like paper clips, safety pins, orphaned earrings, or even a piece of discarded yarn.

They’re categorized as “accessories” in craft work because you don’t actually need to buy them. Alternatives abound everywhere!

I hope that was helpful. If you have any questions, just leave a comment below and I’ll get back to you when I can.

Similar Posts

41 Comments

  1. Emily says:

    I’m an advanced beginner in crochet. Your explanation helps me understand why hat patterns have you slip stitch at the end of each round in spite of the seam it creates. My question is, how do you minimize the “look” of the seam?

    Another question–if you decide to work in the spiral, (say you were making a hat), how would you ensure it didn’t warp or at least minimize it?

  2. Claire says:

    Hi Emily!
    I think it all depends on what stitches you’re working for the pattern. For sc stitches, the seam and the uneven end in the spiral aren’t as obvious as for taller stitches.
    To reduce the look of the seam, don’t count the ladder chains as stitches (beginning chains in the round). For example, if you’re working dc stitches, do the ch 3 or ch 2 at the beginning of the round, but still make a dc in the first stitch–ignore that beginning ch 3 or ch 2.
    For working in the spiral, make sure to anchor the last stitch of the spiral to an appropriate stitch in the round below. For example, if we work in sc, at the end of the spiral we sl st into the next stitch, and all’s well. But for taller stitches, skip a stitch or two before making a sl st, so the shape will come out more uniform.

  3. kaytea says:

    i personally find that ignoring the chain makes all the difference, though with projects such as granny squares, it makes it (very) slightly bigger. also, i only chain1 for sc, 1 for hdc, 2 for dc, and 3 for trc. i gotitin my head as a beginner that single meant 1ch, double meant 2 ch,ect.

  4. tamstrunk says:

    I always have trouble crocheting in the round no matter how tight or how loose I make my stitches. My round always wants to turn into a bowl within the first couple of rows & it just continues to worsen. How do I eliminate this problem??

    • Claire says:

      Hello tamstrunk. :) You might want to check out some of Rachel’s very helpful and relevant posts: How to Crochet a Circle, or if you want to make squares, How to Crochet a Granny Square. I think making work lie flat is more dependent on making the right number of stitches per round, and less on the hook and yarn used. Be sure to always increase the right number of stitches per round. For example, when making a circle and you start with 8 stitches in the first round, be sure to increase 8 stitches each round, and using the same kind of stitch too.

  5. Barbra says:

    Very helpful! Thanks.

  6. Ann says:

    That is interesting and helpful. Thanks.

  7. Marilyn Levy says:

    I hate using stitch markers. If I want to make a hat, which usually calls for the spiral method, can I substitute the traditional way and have it come out the right way? I have not tried it yet but hope to hear that it can be done! thanks.

  8. Shelli says:

    I am fairly new to crocheting and this is what I have a problem with. Thanks for the info.

  9. tamstrunk says:

    Thanks Claire! I will try the circle pattern prior to the beanie & see what happens! I keep hearing how easy it is to crochet in the round!

  10. layla says:

    Hi
    Thank you for new idea. I learn evry day new thing from you thank a lot
    layla

  11. Cary2Crafty says:

    I am so glad you posted this article! I make lots of chemo hats, and am constantly fretting over the look of that joining seam. I’m going to have to try some of these suggestions out soon. I hope to see more suggestions on this post from others who have solved the dilemma of the visible join.

  12. Gerry Stone says:

    In using the join and ch1 at the beginning of the 2nd row, do you then crochet in the joining st, or the st after that? I have done the ch1 and join only once and ended up with extra stitches. I also did not like the slight line it produced in my hats.

    Also doing a spiral hat with colors at the bottom how does one eliminate the uneven jog when you join the new yarn?

    I’m and 87-yr old newbie to crochet and am self-tauft so there are MANY, MANY things I am still learning.

    • Claire says:

      Hello Gerry, Wow! I hope I never stop learning, too, if I turn out to be blessed enough to reach your age!
      My personal preference is, to join the last stitch of the round to the first stitch (not the chain one, if we’re doing sc’s). Some people like to do this join in the back loop only of that first stitch for the round, and it does decrease the visibility of that line we get.
      When working in spirals, that uneven jog you get when you change colors can be made less visible. If say, the hat is made with sc stitches, don’t change colors while working in spiral. Close that first color first by joining the last stitch to the next sc below, and then change to the other color.

  13. MARCIA says:

    Hi Claire. Working in a spiral, you do slip stitch into the last stitch of the previous row to begin a new row? You have to connect it? Thanks

  14. Denise says:

    I need some help in changing from SC to HDC in spiral crochet. How do I do that?!
    (I keep ending at the same level (height) and not above the last rnd)
    Thanks

    • Rachel says:

      Hi Denise, you can replace the sc with the hdc stitches. When you work in a spiral you won’t have the join at the end of the rounds. If you do join at the end of the rounds then each of the rounds will be leveled. I’m not sure if I answered your question, so please let me know if you need more help.

  15. Denise says:

    Thanks for your reply. But I’m not getting it right… Since the HDC is higher it looks kind of wierd at the end of first hdc round.
    (Do you have a tutorial?)

  16. JOANN says:

    thank you Rachel. I will practice and practice.

  17. Krystal says:

    I have a question… what do you do when you want to start with the traditional way and then switch to the spiral? One of the pattern I’m reading tells me to do this but if it creates a visible hole…

    Thanks!

    • Rachel says:

      Hi Krystal, you can switch by omitting the joins when you start the spiral rounds. As you crochet the hole shouldn’t be as noticeable. If it really bothers you can go always go back and sew it shut with a scrap of yarn, but it really shouldn’t be that big of a hole.

  18. juanita says:

    I have made a circle of 14 rounds and want to finish it off by squaring it how do I do this?

    • Rachel Choi says:

      Hi Jaunita, what do you mean by squaring it? Are you trying to turn the circle into a square? Please let me know and explain further, and I’ll help you out :)

      • juanita says:

        yes I am working a pattern for a circle in a square motif but I really want to made a round afghan and then for the last few rounds turn it into a square.

        • Rachel Choi says:

          Oh ok, there are a few different ways you can do it depending on how you want it to look. You can play around with different stitches to see what you like, but the basic idea to turn a circle into a square is to make the 4 corners stand out. Each corner should be a cluster of stitches, about 3 sc or 4 dc into one stitch where you want the corner to be. Since the sides are flat you’d make 1 stitch for each stitch along the side until you get to where you want the next corner to be. Here’s a basic pattern for a square worked in the round to give you a better idea: How to Crochet a Square
          Have fun experimenting with it!!

  19. Patti Z says:

    Thank you. At least now I know it wasn’t something I was doing wrong.

  20. annmarie says:

    I am making an oblong casserole dish cover. The pattern calls for working in the round . How in the world does that work with an oblong dish? Can you help me?

    • Rachel Choi says:

      Hi Annmarie,
      Almost any shape can be created by crocheting in the round. For your item, it sounds like you’ll be crocheting something like an oval. To do that you would start with a long chain. Then crochet the edges with increase to create a curve and the flat sides without increases. Here’s an example of a placemat set, which is a bunch of different shapes that are all crocheted in the round: Crochet Pattern: Placemat Set

  21. Brittany says:

    When you start a new row (in a hdc beanie) do you start with the chain the slip stitch is in or the one after? My rows keep being one or two chains short every row.

    • Rachel Choi says:

      Hi Brittany!
      It would depend on the pattern. Most of the time if you are ending with a slip stitch into the beginning chain you wouldn’t work into the beginning chain on the next round. If you are ending with a slip stitch into the first hdc, then you would probably need to work into the first hdc on the next round.
      Try counting the stitches when you are done working the round, starting with the first round. That way you know you’ve made the correct number and know where to start and stop the next round.

  22. Sam says:

    Hi!
    I’m working on making a no-sew pair of fingerless gloves and I’m working in the round in a spiral and I want a nice, clean, even edge. I’m really confused on how to do that since it’s all just spiraling upwards around the glove.

    Thanks!

  23. polychromatix says:

    I’m making a tote bag in the spiral method using single crochet, and the project just keeps getting smaller and smaller as I go along. Why? Is it because I don’t throw in a few random extra stitches every so often?

    Also, the left edge is going in an S/ vase shape, and the right edge is going in a diagonal. Why?

    • Rachel Choi says:

      Hello! It sounds like you may be skipping stitches by accident. It’s really easy to miss stitches when you are crocheting in the round, especially if there are a lot of stitches. The best thing to do is to count the stitches as you crochet each round. You can place a stitch marker at the beginning of the round and move it again when you meet it again at the end. If there are the same number of stitches on each round then each round will be the same, so you’ll get a consistent size throughout.

  24. Holly says:

    Can someone help me with the following? Ch1, HDC in same stitch. Where exactly does my hook go to do that HDC? Is this what causes the seam? Because if it is, I will just crochet it with stitch markers instead.

  25. Judy says:

    Experienced at crochet but do not understand how to determine the number of stitches to increase in order to make the piece lay flat. If I have a pattern…no problem otherwise I just have to guess at when to increase. Arrrgh!

Leave a Reply